Heat Pumps comparisons
Heat pump readiness, fabric-first sequencing and system choices, assessed objectively.
Heat pump readinessHeat Pump vs Gas Boiler: The Fabric-First View
A heat pump rewards a home with low heat loss and runs efficiently at low flow temperatures; a gas boiler can brute-force heat into a leaky home but masks fabric faults. The fabric-first principle is to reduce heat loss before or alongside fitting a heat pump, so it can be sized correctly and run efficiently.
Read comparisonHeat Pump Readiness: Fabric-First vs System-First
Fabric-first reduces heat loss before the heat pump is sized, so the pump is smaller, runs cooler and costs less to run; system-first installs the pump to suit the house as it stands. Fabric-first is almost always the better long-term engineering decision because heat-pump efficiency depends on flow temperature, which depends on heat loss and emitter sizing. System-first can make sense where deep fabric work is impractical now, but it should be planned so the fabric can still be improved without oversizing the plant.
Read comparisonAir Source vs Ground Source Heat Pump
An ASHP takes heat from the outside air and is cheaper and simpler to install; a GSHP takes heat from the more stable ground and is more efficient but far more costly because of the ground loops or boreholes. For most UK homes an ASHP is the pragmatic choice; a GSHP can pay back where there is suitable land or a long-term, high-demand case and the higher capital is justified. In both cases the fabric and emitter design matter more to real performance than the source itself.
Read comparisonHeat Pump Sizing: Room-by-Room vs Rule of Thumb
A room-by-room heat-loss calculation sizes the heat pump and emitters from the building's actual fabric and losses; a rule of thumb guesses from floor area or the old boiler. Accurate sizing is essential for heat pumps because efficiency depends on low flow temperatures and correctly sized emitters — and oversizing causes cycling, higher cost and poor comfort. Rule-of-thumb sizing is the single most common cause of badly performing heat-pump installations.
Read comparisonLow-Temperature vs High-Temperature Heat Pump System
A low-temperature system runs the heat pump at 35–45°C for maximum efficiency, but needs larger emitters and a modest heat loss; a high-temperature system runs at 55–65°C to suit existing radiators, at the cost of efficiency and running cost. Low-temperature design is the goal because efficiency falls as flow temperature rises. High-temperature systems are a pragmatic bridge where emitter or fabric upgrades are not yet possible, not the efficient end-state.
Read comparisonUnderfloor Heating vs Radiators with a Heat Pump
Underfloor heating is the ideal heat-pump emitter because its large surface delivers heat at very low flow temperatures, maximising efficiency; correctly sized radiators also work well and are far simpler to retrofit. The choice is rarely either/or: underfloor heating suits ground floors, new builds and major refurbishments, while upsized radiators suit most retrofits. What matters is that whichever emitter is used, it must deliver each room's heat at a low flow temperature.
Read comparison